Anonymous comment, adapted:
You also spoke about teachers becoming institutionalised, and about how spiritual absence may have started to seem normal. I truly hope that is not the case – at least not for most of them.
Could the reason be the teacher’s professional persona: that the professional self and the private self are kept apart? The professional self tries to follow the rules and regulations of society and organisations, to act correctly and as expected. The personal self, on the other hand, is protected by a shell, because work can bring along rather heavy things and situations. Sometimes protecting oneself is necessary.
Can genuine encounters still arise? I claim that they can. I truly hope that every young person, student and human being is met genuinely and with acceptance – and also feels that they have been met.
The retreat did happen, and it was an enormously big experience. There were seven participants besides me and the other facilitator, and it included many important experiences, both my own and the participants’.
There is plenty to integrate.
From this vantage point, I want to share what I see.
I do not mean to judge or criticise. It matters to me to write out what I see and experience, so that I can stand behind it. To set healthy boundaries through this.
You made it possible in practice for this retreat journey to happen, and it is an incredibly vast gift to me.
The difference in my experience between how precisely retreat work – bringing people into their bodies – can bring people, and how people can be brought in society’s institutions, is like night and day.
That is why I included your reply to me as a quote above.
The professional persona is, in some sense, necessary in a retreat context too, but at the same time much more of something genuine must be allowed to show from underneath than what institutional cultures are used to, or what the frameworks allow. And “genuine” cannot be allowed to show before the so-called adult in charge in the institution is themselves aware of the layers of their own self – very few have an idea of what genuineness or real adulthood, really standing in and behind oneself, means.
And of course I understand that one must protect oneself when situations can be harsh. In that sense I am grateful to society’s institutions for offering structures that partly protect also sensitive and delicate work, which makes change on a different level possible.
Genuineness means different things at different levels and at different stages of development for different people. Of course a person can experience being “genuinely” met and supported in steps forward in their story also in educational or social welfare institutions. What has been painful for me is how little finally gets to show from under the shells. How much institutions in practice, and largely unconsciously, still pass on to the next generations the same patterns of action and behaviour. How much damage, caused by people who thought they knew, has had to be repaired afterwards, once they realised the stories were not connected to reality.
“Correct and as expected” looks to me like a very coarse aim in institutions for what acting with people in mind could really mean. In the other pan of the scale is the human innermost self, which strives to become fully visible and needs support in feeling and recognising it, in walking their own path, so that they can know what they are ultimately doing in the world. If this does not happen, we only create more detours while imagining we are helping.
The way you defend people in institutions is, on the one hand, beautiful loyalty, and on the other hand I strongly question it. The world has been shaped by the people in positions of responsibility, and no one in today’s world can escape how the almost complete neglect of inner work in mainstream culture has driven the world into dire straits. Just a quick glance at the news makes this obvious to me.
The next generations are already moving toward a more open understanding of humanity, and from this perspective talk of professional personas and roles looks a bit petrified. Stories of the mental level, of the mind, which for the most part have no touch with holistic, body- and feeling-level humanity. There seems to be a lot of half-knowing in the previous generations, and less seeing of where the younger ones are already heading.
This is my grief. Ylva Haru - Kunnes katsomme (YouTube)
“If I wish to lead a person toward a certain goal, I must first find out where he is and begin there. He who cannot do this deceives himself when he thinks he can help others.
To help someone, I must of course understand more than he does, but above all I must understand what he understands. If I cannot do that, it is of no help even if I could and knew more. If I nevertheless wanted to show how much I know, it is because I am vain and proud and really want the other person to admire me instead of being helped by me.
All genuine willingness to help begins with humility before the one I want to help. Then I must understand that helping is not about wanting to dominate, but about wanting to serve. If I cannot do this, I cannot help others either.”
Søren Kierkegaard, translator unknown
